A federal appeals court on November 17, 2026, refused to block Maryland from enforcing its gambling laws against Kalshi, affirming the denial of the company’s preliminary injunction request.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 against Kalshi, according to CBS News Baltimore and Gambling.com, upholding an August 2025 federal district court decision.
The ruling concerns only a preliminary injunction, so the underlying lawsuit against officials at the Maryland Lottery and Gaming Control Agency continues and no final judgment has been entered.
The decision adds to a growing split among federal appeals courts over whether federal commodities law shields sports event contracts from state gambling rules.
A Divided Panel Issues Three Separate Opinions
The panel issued a published per curiam opinion, a decision issued in the name of the court rather than a single judge, according to VitalLaw’s Securities Regulation Daily.
Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker joined the outcome but each wrote a separate concurring opinion, while Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin dissented.
The court concluded that Kalshi had not shown that the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) preempts Maryland’s sports wagering laws.
Kalshi had argued that federal preemption, the principle that federal law can override conflicting state rules, places designated contract markets under the exclusive jurisdiction of the CFTC.
Gregory concluded that even if Kalshi’s sports event contracts qualify as swaps under the CEA, federal law does not clearly preempt Maryland’s traditional authority to regulate gambling, Gambling Insider reported.
He reasoned that the CEA’s exclusive-jurisdiction provision must be read alongside its special rules for gaming contracts.
He also rejected the argument that Maryland’s licensing requirements conflict with federal law, because the company could comply with both regimes.
Benjamin, the lone dissenter, argued that the contracts are swaps and that the CEA preempts Maryland’s gambling laws.
Because Gregory and Thacker reached the same result for different reasons, the outcome carries a majority but no single majority rationale.
Dispute Began With a Cease-and-Desist Letter
Maryland gaming authorities sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter on April 7, saying it was offering services without a required license, CBS News Baltimore reported.
Two weeks later, Kalshi went to federal court seeking to bar the state from enforcing its sports betting laws against the company.
The district court denied that request in August 2025, and Kalshi appealed to the Fourth Circuit.
Bloomberg Law reported that the divided panel held Kalshi’s sports prediction markets are likely subject to Maryland’s gambling laws.
Maryland had agreed not to enforce its gambling laws against Kalshi until the Fourth Circuit ruled, according to InGame.
With the ruling issued, Maryland may sue Kalshi in state court and try to have its sports contracts banned in the state, InGame reported.
Maryland has not said whether it will pursue further enforcement action, according to Covers.
Maryland and Kalshi Offer Competing Readings
Maryland Attorney General Anthony Brown praised the ruling and said federal commodities rules were never designed to provide consumer safeguards.
“Today’s ruling means Kalshi must meet the same consumer protection standards as every other sportsbook serving Maryland residents,” Brown said.
A Kalshi spokesperson responded on November 18 by pointing to the split in the judges’ reasoning: “Judges can’t agree with each other on why we’re wrong.”
In a statement to Reuters on November 17, Kalshi said the decision “demonstrates there is no unified coherent legal argument against prediction markets.”
Those statements reflect the company’s position, but the court’s judgment still went against Kalshi on the injunction.
For Maryland bettors, the dispute centers on whether Kalshi’s sports contracts must carry the same licensing and consumer protections as state-regulated sportsbooks.
Appellate Split Points Toward the Supreme Court
Three federal appeals courts have now ruled against Kalshi’s efforts to avoid state gambling rules, while the Third Circuit has supported the company’s position, Covers reported.
New Jersey asked the Supreme Court in September to consider its appeal of the Third Circuit case, according to InGame.
Gambling Insider reported that all three Fourth Circuit judges reached different conclusions on the CFTC’s authority over sports event contracts, adding to the appellate split.
Covers said that, until the Supreme Court intervenes, the ruling leaves Maryland closer to enforcing its restrictions and adds a legal obstacle to prediction markets’ plans to offer sports contracts nationwide.